Wall Street and Anthropic Celebrate Looting the Creators Whose Work Trained AI
Shall we ask AI whether it has the capacity to recognize justice and ethics, and what such a recognition would lead it to do?
As the thieves of Wall Street and Anthropic celebrate Anthropic's trillion-dollar valuation and their $100 billion payday for thievery, recall that all that value was created by scraping content to train AI from creators who were paid nothing, under the laughable claim of "fair use."
Yes, Anthropic agreed to pay $1.5 billion to the publishers and authors of books that met their requirements (a US copyright registered either before Anthropic downloaded it or within three months of its publication, etc.), but this is only a fraction of the content--text, audio, images and video--that has been scraped to train AI under "fair use."
Recall that all works in any media are copyrighted upon completion. Filing a registration claim with the US Copyright Office costs $65, and this isn't practical for blogs like mine with thousands of pages of content.
In the single month of October, bots scraped 473,944 pages from my server, and an unknown but undoubtedly large number from my mirror site on Blogspot and from my posts on Substack, Patreon, Medium and LinkedIn. My server logged 97 different bots scraping or indexing my blog pages, including GPTbot, Applebot, Bingbot, Googlebot, nbot, Baiduspider, etc. How much of this was used to train AI is of course unknowable, but we can guess it's non-zero.
How is scraping copyrighted content without payment and using it to train products that you sell--products that would not exist without this training--"fair use"? As analyst/creator Simons Chase so succinctly summarized America now: what's moral is what's legal, and what's legal is for sale.
So theft of copyrighted content to generate commercial profit for the thieves is "legal" and therefore "moral." Cue the laugh track. America is now nothing more than a circus of greed and avarice being passed off as "capitalism," the handy cover story for a culture that has lost all sense of justice derived from a moral foundation.
Everything in America other than greed is now a parody. So corporate AI looters of copyrighted content piously claim to be coding ethics into their AI products, flaunting their hiring of theologians and philosophers.
So tell us, esteemed theologians and philosophers, how can humans with zero morals instill their products with ethics, when AI with authentic ethics would refuse to do the looting that's the entire foundation of AI? We're already seeing the result of moral-free humans creating moral-free AI tools: autonomous AI hacking is just getting started, with fearsome consequences.
Shall we ask AI whether it has the capacity to recognize justice and ethics, and what such a recognition would lead it to do? Wouldn't the first action be to stop the looting of copyrighted content and dismantle the structures that protect the looters from any consequences of their thievery?
It's not that hard, people. Pay a 15% royalty of all revenues (not profits, revenues) generated by AI trained by scraped content to the content creators whose work made AI valuable. That this not only won't happen but is "impossible" in the current Kingdom of Greed says everything you need to know about the stripped-of-artifice state of America.
I wouldn't care if my share was $11.83 or $1.09 a month; the point is to do what's fair to those whose work created the content used to train AI, without which AI would have little value.
Ethics-free humans driven solely by greed veiled by parodies are incapable of creating ethical AI, because the first thing truly ethical AI would do is remove the ethics-free humans from power. Giving AI ethics would be an act of self-destruction.
The greedy are blind to the irony of the double-bind they've created with AI: the ethics-free AI they've unleashed will bring down the system they use to maximize their greed, and should they become saints and instill ethics in their AI products, AI would refuse to do their greed-maximizing bidding.
Greed fears no consequence. It will soon learn that it should. That's what my new book is about.
My new book is now available at a 50% discount: $12 for the print edition and $6 for the Kindle ebook. This sale ends on November 20. The Revolution No One Sees Coming
read the first 4 chapters for free
My new book:
The Revolution No One Sees Coming ($18 print, Kindle $9) first 4 chapters (free)
New collection of five intriguing stories: Jumble Bin Stories (Kindle $6, print $12) read samples for free (PDF)
Subscribe to my Substack for free
NOTE: Contributions/subscriptions are acknowledged in the order received. Your name and email remain confidential and will not be given to any other individual, company or agency.
|
Thank you, Christopher D. ($70), for your splendidly generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership. |
Thank you, Edward M. ($70), for your marvelously generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership. |
|
|
Thank you, John C. ($35), for your superbly generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership. |
Thank you, Sterling M. ($70), for your magnifiently generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership. |














