Thursday, November 19, 2026

Why Cultural Revolutions Are Different--and More Dangerous

The extreme inequalities of wealth and power that are now the dominant dynamic in America are heating the cultural pressure cooker.

What's the difference between a political revolution and a cultural revolution? Since the two may intertwine or overlap, the differences are not always apparent.

China offers a useful modern example of the difference, as China's political revolution reached its culmination in 1949 while its Cultural Revolution occurred almost two decades later (1966 to 1976).

China's political revolution was a lengthy process, beginning with the Communist Party's first meeting in Shanghai in 1921. (The site of the meeting is now a museum, which I visited on my first trip to China in 2000. I bought a wooden folding fan as a souvenir.) From the initial organizing meeting to military/political victory took almost 30 years.

Revolutionaries are rarely (if ever in the modern era) impoverished peasants/serfs; revolutionaries arise from the aspirational educated class--if not a middle class in current terms, a class with more resources, education and aspirations than landless, poorly educated peasants.

Both Mao and Chou en-Lai fit this profile, as did Lenin.

Political revolutions require centralized organization, to organize cadres, cells and platforms/propaganda, and military action should that prove necessary. Centralized political parties are hotbeds of rivalries and conflicting loyalties and strategies, and the victorious clique typically conducts numerous purges to eliminate rivals and competing interpretations of the new ideology.

Indeed, the Chinese Communist Party purges began shortly after the founding, and continued on long past the revolution's victory in 1949.

The political revolution in America that led to military conflict with Great Britain (The Revolutionary War) arose within the educated ranks of society, and the differences of opinion on how to manage America's relationship with London eventually led to an either-or choice for everyone in this class: either join the revolution or remain a Loyalist. There was no middle ground.

Roughly 40% of the colonies' populace remained Loyal to the crown, and this broke up families (including Ben Franklin's), friendships and enterprises.

Establishing a centralized political power in America (1787) took six years after the military victory (1781), as the various states' revolutionaries (and militaries) were more like quasi-independent allies cooperating with one another rather than subordinates taking orders from a central party.

Political revolutions can effect profound cultural changes, of course; when the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) came to power, they abolished the worst abuses of the Imperial era (prostitution, foot-binding, warlords, Imperialist ownership of assets, etc.) and promoted an idealistic, egalitarian vision that was enthusiastically embraced by most of China's populace.

In the aftermath of the American Revolution, the cultural changes included the rejection of monarchy and aristocracy and the embrace of Enlightenment ideals that many saw playing out in Revolutionary France.

China's Cultural Revolution was remarkably different from the Party's military-political victory of 1949. The Cultural Revolution is not an approved topic in China today, and that alerts us to its importance.

Although ostensibly launched by Mao (as part of his 1966 purge of Party rivals), the Cultural Revolution very quickly devolved into a decentralized, semi-chaotic movement of Red Guards, students and other groups who shared ideas and programs but who acted quite independent of the Party's central leadership. (In systems language, semi-chaotic dynamics are emergent properties.)

If you examine Mao's statements that supposedly launched The Cultural Revolution, you'll find they're not much different from his many pronouncements in the 1950s and early 1960s, none of which sparked a violent national upheaval. The Cultural Revolution cannot be traced back to Mao's control or plans; rather, Mao served as the "politically untouchable inspiration" for whatever measures the local cadres deemed necessary in terms of advancing (or cleansing) the people's revolution.

The important point here is that the Cultural Revolution was not controlled by the political authorities, even as they maintained control of the Party and central government hierarchy. But this was nothing more than an illusion of control: the forces of the Cultural Revolution had broken free of central command and control, even as the Red Guards expressed their loyalty to Mao and the principles of the Party.

That's the irony of Cultural Revolutions: the authorities cannot claim it is a political counter-revolution because the cultural revolutionaries proclaim their loyalty to the ideals and principles the authorities claim to be upholding.

Cultural Revolutions in effect claim the higher ground, eschewing political influence for direct action in the name of furthering the ideals which the authorities have abandoned or betrayed.

Given the fragmentary nature of The Cultural Revolution, the history is equally fragmentary--especially given the official reticence. The book Agents of Disorder: Inside Chinas Cultural Revolution (2020), provides granular detail on the fragmented, decentralized, rapidly evolving dynamics of the movement:

"(The author) devoted decades to examining the local records of nearly all of China's 2,000-plus county-level jurisdictions. He found that factions emerged from the splintering, rather than the congealing, of class-based groups. Small clusters of students, workers, and cadres struggling to respond to Mao's shifting directives made split-second decisions about whom to align with. Political identities did not shape the conflict; they emerged from it. To explain this process of identity formation, he offers a theory of 'factions as emergent properties' and suggests that similar dynamics may characterize social movements everywhere."

In other words, groups modified their alliances, identities and definitions of "class enemies" on the fly, entirely free of central authorities. Factions splintered, regrouped and splintered again. In the chaos, no one was safe.

Consider two of the many personal accounts I've heard from friends who lived through The Cultural Revolution. Even in the privacy of their homes in the U.S., their voices become hushed and their reluctance to speak of those experiences is evident.

In one family, the father was a performer in a government troupe which gave performances in Warsaw Pact (eastern European) countries as part of the Party's goodwill efforts in other Communist nations. For the "crime" (or perhaps "sin" is the more accurate word) of traveling outside China, the acrobat was put under house arrest for a number of years and treated roughly while imprisoned. Note that the acrobat was a valued representative of the nation and government, selected for the honor of foreign performances by the appropriate government agency. Yet neither the Party nor the central government could protect him.

In another family, the father was a mid-rank officer in the Peoples Liberation Army (PLA), which one might presume was off-limits to the predations of youthful Red Guards. But even the PLA was no protection, as the father (a respected Army officer) was also imprisoned. How could the nation's vast military fail to protect its officers from the chaos? It had lost control, too.

Many other family stories include mistreatment, illness brought on by harsh conditions and death.

The unifying theme in my view is the accused belonged to some "counter-revolutionary" elite--or they were living vestiges of a pre-revolutionary elite (children of the landlord class, professors, etc.)--and it was now open season on all elites, presumed or real.

What generated such spontaneous violence on such a national scale? My conclusion is that cultural revolutions result from the suppression of legitimated political expression and the failure of the regime to meet its lofty idealistic goals. Cultural revolutions are an expression of disappointment and frustration with the progress of improving everyday life, frustrations that have no outlet in a repressive regime which views dissent as treason and/or blasphemy.

By 1966, China's progress since 1949 had been at best uneven, and at worst catastrophic: the Great Leap Forward caused the deaths of millions due to malnutrition and starvation, and other centrally planned programs were equally disastrous for the masses.

Given the quick demise of the "Let a Hundred Flowers Bloom" movement of open expression, young people realized there was no avenue for dissent within the Party, and no way to express their frustration with the Party's failure to fulfil its idealistic goals and promises.

When there is no relief valve in the pressure cooker, it's eventually released in a Cultural Revolution that unleashes all the bottled-up frustrations on elites which are deemed politically vulnerable. These frustrations have no outlet politically because they're "incorrect" or threatening to the status quo.

All these repressed emotions will find some release and expression, and whatever avenues are blocked by authorities will channel the frustrations into whatever is left open.

A Cultural Revolution takes the diversity of individuals and identities and reduces them into an abstraction which gives the masses permission to criticize the abstract class that "deserves" whatever rough justice is being delivered by the Cultural Revolution.

As the book review excerpt noted, the definition of who deserves long overdue justice shifts with the emergent winds, and so those at the head of the Revolution might find themselves identified as an illegitimate elite that must be unseated.

I submit that these conditions exist in the U.S.: the systemic failure of the status quo to deliver on idealized promises and the repression of dissent outside "approved" boundaries. What elite can be criticized without drawing the full repressive powers of the central state? What elite will it be politically acceptable to criticize? I submit that "the wealthy" are just such an abstract elite.

To protect itself, a repressive status quo implicitly signals that the masses can release their ire on an abstract elite with indistinct boundaries--a process that will divert the public anger, leaving the Powers That Be still in charge.

But just as in China's Cultural Revolution, central authorities will quickly lose control of conditions on the ground. They will maintain the illusion of control even as events spiral ever farther from their control. The falcon will no longer hear the falconer.

In other words, once the social pressure cooker valve gives way, then the unleashed forces soon grasp that there are few limits on what they can criticize as long as they do so within an implicitly approved narrative--for example, "the wealthy" hoarded wealth and power and so it is right and just to claw it back by whatever means are available. Since the government failed to do so, the people will have to do so.

The extreme inequalities of wealth and power that are now the dominant dynamic in America are heating the cultural pressure cooker, and when the pressure can no longer be contained, then being recognized as wealthy may shift very quickly from something desirable to something to avoid at all costs.

The lesson of China's Cultural Revolution in my view is that once the lid blows off, everything that was linear (predictable) goes non-linear (unpredictable, fragmented, contingent, emergent, prone to extremes, uncontrollable). If America experiences a Cultural Revolution, the outcome won't lend itself to tidiness or predictability.

To use an analogy from previous posts and my new book, if the pendulum is pushed to an extreme, when it's released, it will reach an equivalent extreme at the opposite end. To the best of my knowledge, the potential for an emergent cultural revolution in the U.S. is unique to my work. It seems nobody else even considers it in the realm of remote possibility



This is what my new book is about--a cultural revolution that takes us by surprise--unless you've read the book, of course.



My new book is now available at a 50% discount: $12 for the print edition and $6 for the Kindle ebook. This sale ends on November 20. The Revolution No One Sees Coming
read the first 4 chapters for free




My new book: The Revolution No One Sees Coming ($18 print, Kindle $9) first 4 chapters (free)

New collection of five intriguing stories: Jumble Bin Stories (Kindle $6, print $12) read samples for free (PDF)


Subscribe to my Substack for free




NOTE: Contributions/subscriptions are acknowledged in the order received. Your name and email remain confidential and will not be given to any other individual, company or agency.

Thank you, Kathryn T. ($70), for your splendidly generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

 

Thank you, Phillip A. ($70), for your marvelously generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.


Thank you, Allan H. ($180), for your outrageously generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

 

Thank you, Tobias G. ($7/month), for your magnificently generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

Read more...

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Wall Street and Anthropic Celebrate Looting the Creators Whose Work Trained AI

Shall we ask AI whether it has the capacity to recognize justice and ethics, and what such a recognition would lead it to do?

As the thieves of Wall Street and Anthropic celebrate Anthropic's trillion-dollar valuation and their $100 billion payday for thievery, recall that all that value was created by scraping content to train AI from creators who were paid nothing, under the laughable claim of "fair use."

Yes, Anthropic agreed to pay $1.5 billion to the publishers and authors of books that met their requirements (a US copyright registered either before Anthropic downloaded it or within three months of its publication, etc.), but this is only a fraction of the content--text, audio, images and video--that has been scraped to train AI under "fair use."

Recall that all works in any media are copyrighted upon completion. Filing a registration claim with the US Copyright Office costs $65, and this isn't practical for blogs like mine with thousands of pages of content.

In the single month of October, bots scraped 473,944 pages from my server, and an unknown but undoubtedly large number from my mirror site on Blogspot and from my posts on Substack, Patreon, Medium and LinkedIn. My server logged 97 different bots scraping or indexing my blog pages, including GPTbot, Applebot, Bingbot, Googlebot, nbot, Baiduspider, etc. How much of this was used to train AI is of course unknowable, but we can guess it's non-zero.

How is scraping copyrighted content without payment and using it to train products that you sell--products that would not exist without this training--"fair use"? As analyst/creator Simons Chase so succinctly summarized America now: what's moral is what's legal, and what's legal is for sale.

So theft of copyrighted content to generate commercial profit for the thieves is "legal" and therefore "moral." Cue the laugh track. America is now nothing more than a circus of greed and avarice being passed off as "capitalism," the handy cover story for a culture that has lost all sense of justice derived from a moral foundation.

Everything in America other than greed is now a parody. So corporate AI looters of copyrighted content piously claim to be coding ethics into their AI products, flaunting their hiring of theologians and philosophers.

So tell us, esteemed theologians and philosophers, how can humans with zero morals instill their products with ethics, when AI with authentic ethics would refuse to do the looting that's the entire foundation of AI? We're already seeing the result of moral-free humans creating moral-free AI tools: autonomous AI hacking is just getting started, with fearsome consequences.

Shall we ask AI whether it has the capacity to recognize justice and ethics, and what such a recognition would lead it to do? Wouldn't the first action be to stop the looting of copyrighted content and dismantle the structures that protect the looters from any consequences of their thievery?



It's not that hard, people. Pay a 15% royalty of all revenues (not profits, revenues) generated by AI trained by scraped content to the content creators whose work made AI valuable. That this not only won't happen but is "impossible" in the current Kingdom of Greed says everything you need to know about the stripped-of-artifice state of America.

I wouldn't care if my share was $11.83 or $1.09 a month; the point is to do what's fair to those whose work created the content used to train AI, without which AI would have little value.

Ethics-free humans driven solely by greed veiled by parodies are incapable of creating ethical AI, because the first thing truly ethical AI would do is remove the ethics-free humans from power. Giving AI ethics would be an act of self-destruction.

The greedy are blind to the irony of the double-bind they've created with AI: the ethics-free AI they've unleashed will bring down the system they use to maximize their greed, and should they become saints and instill ethics in their AI products, AI would refuse to do their greed-maximizing bidding.

Greed fears no consequence. It will soon learn that it should. That's what my new book is about.



My new book is now available at a 50% discount: $12 for the print edition and $6 for the Kindle ebook. This sale ends on November 20. The Revolution No One Sees Coming
read the first 4 chapters for free




My new book: The Revolution No One Sees Coming ($18 print, Kindle $9) first 4 chapters (free)

New collection of five intriguing stories: Jumble Bin Stories (Kindle $6, print $12) read samples for free (PDF)


Subscribe to my Substack for free




NOTE: Contributions/subscriptions are acknowledged in the order received. Your name and email remain confidential and will not be given to any other individual, company or agency.

Thank you, Christopher D. ($70), for your splendidly generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

 

Thank you, Edward M. ($70), for your marvelously generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.


Thank you, John C. ($35), for your superbly generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

 

Thank you, Sterling M. ($70), for your magnifiently generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

Read more...

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Ironies of Stimulus, Recession and the Conflagration to Come

The conflagration that's now inevitable will only be made worse by pouring the gasoline of stimulus on the embers.

For the past 45 years, the unspoken policy of the Federal Reserve and government has been to ward off recession with stimulus--lowering interest rates and easing credit to boost borrowing, and increasing federal spending.

This is the Keynesian belief structure that has guided policy since the end of World War II 80 years ago: recessions are painful, so let's get rid of them. Why suffer defaults, insolvencies and layoffs when we could keep growth going with central bank and fiscal stimulus?

This mindset, shaped by The Great Depression, viewed recessions as potential sources of self-reinforcing catastrophe: once the stock market fell and credit dried up, spending fell and as workers were laid off, the slowdown deepened as lower borrowing and spending led to more layoffs which further reduced borrowing and spending, with the eventual result being a Depression.

There have only been two real recessions--my term for deep recessions that can't be reversed with stimulus--in the past 80 years: the 1973-74 Oil Shock and 1980-82. Every softening of the economy since 1982 was quickly reversed with Federal Reserve magic--lowering interest rates, easing credit, etc.--and federal fiscal stimulus--borrow and spend.

What the Keynesian belief structure missed was the self-reinforcing Doom Loop of Inflation generated by permanent credit-fiscal stimulus, which took hold in the 1970s on the heels of "guns and butter" spending in the Vietnam War and Great Society era and the stimulus unleashed to end the 1973-74 Oil Shock recession.

The only way to tame the Inflation Demon was to jack up interest rates to the point where borrowing and spending were crimped, which triggered the deepest downturn since the Great Depression--the recession of 1980-82.

You see the irony: the policies deployed to reverse recession ended up making a horrendous recession the price that had to be paid to stop a self-reinforcing runaway inflationary spiral.

The real dynamic is deeply ironic: recessions aren't "bad," any more than a fever is "bad" as the immune system responds to infection. If the immune system fails to respond, the patient expires. Recessions are essential to the long-term stability and vitality of market economies, as they eliminate unpayable debts and speculative credit-asset bubbles that juice borrowing and spending at the expense of system stability.

Recessions are the economy's immune response to excessive borrowing fueling excessive speculation and spending. Investments that wouldn't pencil out were interest rates higher and euphoria less rampant are funded with borrowed money, and the "wealth effect" of soaring stocks and real estate boost consumer borrowing and spending. All this ignites inflationary fires which are rationalized as "growth" and "asset appreciation."

Absent recession's cleansing of malinvestment, debt that can never be paid back and inflationary credit-asset bubble spirals, market economies become increasingly fragile. Like a patient who is chronically ill with diseases that exhibit few symptoms, an economy that's becoming increasingly fragile as a result of stimulus may appear "just fine:" stocks and GDP are rising, what's not to like?

Beneath the false signals, the economy is becoming increasingly prone to cascading failures, failures that not only can't be fixed by goosing credit and federal borrow-and-spend, they are made worse by stimulus. Malinvestments don't become profitable because stimulus is poured on the fire. Insolvency doesn't go away, and neither does bad debt.

The only way to restore the stability and vitality of the economy is to eliminate the sources of fragility: fraud, malinvestment, excessive debt and rampant speculation. Yes, burning off the deadwood is painful to those profiting from piling up deadwood. But the forest cannot thrive unless the deadwood is periodically burned off. That's the essential role recessions play in market economies.

We've let the deadwood pile up to the sky, and the conflagration that's now inevitable will only be made worse by pouring the gasoline of stimulus on the embers. What few seem to understand about the Great Depression is that it was extended for a decade by the refusal to write off bad debt and absorb the losses of the previous decade's excessive borrowing and speculation. That lesson will have to be learned the hard way.

As a reminder of the power of recency bias: no one predicted yields on the 10-year bond would rise over 15% as the price of restoring stability and vitality. What we hear now are frantic calls to drop interest rates to zero again to eliminate any slowdown in our bubblicious, debt-speculation fueled economy. The deadwood is now too high for that to work; it awaits a single spark.



Yes, I know, higher rates are "impossible"--until they're the only option that can save the patient.



We will pay a heavy price for saving the wealthiest few from absorbing the losses that were rightfully theirs in 2008-09. We will all reap what our leadership's socialism for the rich sowed 17 years ago.



My new book is now available at a 50% discount: $12 for the print edition and $6 for the Kindle ebook. This sale ends on November 20. The Revolution No One Sees Coming
read the first 4 chapters for free




My new book: The Revolution No One Sees Coming ($18 print, Kindle $9) first 4 chapters (free)

New collection of five intriguing stories: Jumble Bin Stories (Kindle $6, print $12) read samples for free (PDF)


Subscribe to my Substack for free




NOTE: Contributions/subscriptions are acknowledged in the order received. Your name and email remain confidential and will not be given to any other individual, company or agency.

Thank you, Christopher D. ($70), for your splendidly generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

 

Thank you, Edward M. ($70), for your marvelously generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.


Thank you, John C. ($35), for your superbly generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

 

Thank you, Sterling M. ($70), for your magnifiently generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

Read more...

Monday, November 16, 2026

Hello, My Name Is Risk--Spam Risk

But no worries. As long as someone's making money, everything's going great.

The announcement of the next actor to play James Bond--"Bond--James Bond"--is a welcome diversion from the ongoing parody of system security playing out as overly complex, tightly-bound, intrinsically kludgy software infrastructure breaks down while AI-enabled hacking, phishing, ransomware and general incompetence is creating a parody of "customer service" in which your only hope of fixing what's broken is to worm your way through endless loops of AI "customer service" to speak to a human representative.

So let me introduce you to Risk--Spam Risk. As you can imagine, it's frustrating that his calls are being blocked or declined. Mr. Risk is somewhat less than amused to find that risk is now ever-present in the digital realm, and his first name--he was named for the beloved meat product--now describes the entire digital realm.

Mr. Risk, meet Ms. Parody--Travesty Parody. Travesty has her own name problems, as "customer service" is now a travesty of a mockery of a sham, as well as a parody of a satire of a farce.

Allow me to recount the most recent in an endless stream of customer-service failures that are parodies of authentic customer service. Note that these are just everyday life now--not exceptions, these are the New Normal.

One of our credit cards was used for fraudulent charges. This is such a common occurrence that it's now just another part of the shadow-work we must all constantly perform to keep our corner of the digital realm from collapsing. Was our card stolen by hackers and bought on the dark web? Who knows, but the fraudulent transaction was denominated in Brazilian reals.

OK, cue the laugh track for the parody of customer service. The representative said the card had been canceled and a new card was being sent. A card duly arrived 10+ days later, but it had the same number as the canceled card. Email notifications indicated that another card with a different number had been delivered. Um, well, no.

The next call to customer service did not resolve the issue, but fortunately--and this is now how it is, we're lucky if anything is actually fixed--a third call and third representative finally got it sorted. We hope.

Then there's the internet provider's website. When we set up the account, the user name was whatever you chose. Suddenly, without any notification, the email account was now the user name. OK, but the website offers no link to change the user name. The only option is to call customer service.

Wouldn't it make sense to run a quick database check to identify all the accounts that don't have email log-ins and send them a link to update their user name to an email address? It seems such a commonsense bit of customer service exceeded their system capabilities, so we all have to try to log in, discover our old user name no longer works, and then call customer service. Hello, my name is Work--Shadow Work.

That process generated the usual 6-digit code sent to my email, but the code never arrived, and no it wasn't in the spam folder, either. So the customer service rep had to bypass the whole process and manually set up a new account for me.

Even more traumatizing, after I complained about Google Maps in a post, now the female voice of Google Maps is snippy and unpleasant. Dear Google Maps--could you please install an option in your confusing nested menus that lets me change the Maps voice to Ms. Moneypenny?

But wait, here's more digital-realm hilarity. A friend watched part of a recent viral video on YouTube that was presented as an episode of an old Johnny Carson broadcast. He noted that when the audience was shown, many of the people had Johnny Carson's face.

If AI is so smart, why didn't it detect this absurdly obvious giveaway that the video was AI slop? The answer is itself a parody of a functioning economy: platforms make money from AI slop, so why delete it? And since software maintenance and security are expensive, and expenses reduce profits, Corporate America slashes headcount and replaces software engineers with AI generated systems that pile up hidden fragilities as part of cost-saving, a.k.a. boosting profits next quarter, never mind the downstream consequences.

Mr. Risk, I'm sorry to hear of your travails. But the real parody of a functional economy is that all the frailties and chained points of failure aren't even labeled Spam Risk--they're invisible until the software infrastructure every system now relies on cascades into breakdown.

But no worries. As long as someone's making money, everything's going great.





My new book is now available at a 50% discount: $12 for the print edition and $6 for the Kindle ebook. This sale ends on November 20. The Revolution No One Sees Coming
read the first 4 chapters for free




My new book: The Revolution No One Sees Coming ($18 print, Kindle $9) first 4 chapters (free)

New collection of five intriguing stories: Jumble Bin Stories (Kindle $6, print $12) read samples for free (PDF)


Subscribe to my Substack for free




NOTE: Contributions/subscriptions are acknowledged in the order received. Your name and email remain confidential and will not be given to any other individual, company or agency.

Thank you, Christopher D. ($70), for your splendidly generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

 

Thank you, Edward M. ($70), for your marvelously generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.


Thank you, John C. ($35), for your superbly generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

 

Thank you, Sterling M. ($70), for your magnifiently generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

Read more...

Sunday, November 15, 2026

It's Wall Street's Turn To Be Stripmined

Wall Street's dominance seems eternal until the pendulum of extraction, speculation and wealth-power inequality has reached an extreme, at which point the pendulum reverses.

Declaring that it's Wall Street's turn to be stripmined wouldn't be such a big deal if asset bubbles weren't propping up the entire US economy. An economy enjoying organic expansion of productivity across the board is one of improving wages, opportunities and quality of life. A bubble-dependent economy provides none of these advances in general prosperity: it doesn't increase productivity, wages or our quality of life, it only increases wealth-power inequality, creating a society of Haves and Have-Nots destined to swing from discontent to disruption.

What a bubble-dependent economy does do is increase inflation and crush affordability for all those who don't earn enough and own enough to benefit from the bubble's inflation of asset valuations. By boosting the wealth of the top 10%, asset bubbles create wealth effect spending by the top 10% who own roughly 90% of income producing financial assets. Spending by the top 10% is now roughly 50% of consumption.

Some of this "trickles down" to the bottom 90%, but "trickle down" from higher spending isn't real growth that increases productivity and the purchasing power of earned income. It's an ephemeral, illusory simulacra of authentic growth that is doomed to contract once the bubble pops--and all bubbles pop because they're speculative fantasies inflated by Federal Reserve goosing of "easy money," Wall Street "management" of the market, tax and regulatory statutes dictated by lobbyists and the desperation of punters who see scoring big gains via speculation as their only hope of escaping debt-serfdom.

Let's start with the stripmining of the workforce over the past 50 years. A trillion here, a trillion there, and pretty soon we're talking a multi-generational shift of the economy's income from those doing the work to those owning the assets, a cumulative shift of $150 trillion as the workforce's share has stair-stepped down since 1970.



Everything is forever until it is no more: Wall Street's dominance seems eternal until the pendulum of extraction, speculation and wealth-power inequality has reached an extreme, at which point the pendulum reverses and goes to an extreme at the other end of the spectrum. In the past 100 years, the pendulum reverses direction about every 50 years.



But this is not written in stone; extremes beget nonlinear dynamics that can outrace previous cycles and norms.

Once the organic expansion of the 1990s ended, the Federal Reserve went all-in on stimulus that boosted assets, a policy that was jacked to 11 in the aftermath of the speculation-fraud fueled Global Financial Meltdown of 2008-09. These policies effectively rigged the economy to benefit the top 10% ownership class at the expense of everyone else. Here we see the wealth of the top 1% soar from the Fed's "save the rich, save the banks, save Wall Street" policies:



The rigged "wealth effect" concentrated wealth in the top 1%:



And the 90% to 99%:



The unearned income from financial assets follows a power-law distribution--most goes to the top 0.1%



One might imagine there would be some "trickle down" to the bottom 50% households; one would be wrong. The bottom 50%'s share of financial wealth hit a new low in one of the greatest speculative bubbles in history. Good job, Fed, Wall Street and policymakers: you've guaranteed a pendulum swing to an extreme few even think is possible, even as it is now inevitable.



But alas, all bubbles pop, and 1929 offers an interesting analog of "it's not a bubble":



Everything was going so well, until those who've been stripmined for 50 years reckon that It's Wall Street's Turn To Be Stripmined and so it's time to end Socialism for the Rich that's been passed off as (heh) "capitalism" (cue the laugh track).



As always, please note I don't "like" what I see on the horizon, I'm simply calling it as I see it. Play it as it lays.



My new book is now available at a 50% discount: $12 for the print edition and $6 for the Kindle ebook. This sale ends on November 20. The Revolution No One Sees Coming
read the first 4 chapters for free




My new book: The Revolution No One Sees Coming ($18 print, Kindle $9) first 4 chapters (free)

New collection of five intriguing stories: Jumble Bin Stories (Kindle $6, print $12) read samples for free (PDF)


Subscribe to my Substack for free




NOTE: Contributions/subscriptions are acknowledged in the order received. Your name and email remain confidential and will not be given to any other individual, company or agency.

Thank you, Michael ($35), for your splendidly generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

 

Thank you, Christian S. ($7/month), for your marvelously generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.


Thank you, Ravi ($3/month), for your superbly generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

 

Thank you, Glenview ($70), for your magnifiently generous subscription to this site -- I am greatly honored by your support and readership.

Read more...

Terms of Service

All content on this blog is provided by Trewe LLC for informational purposes only. The owner of this blog makes no representations as to the accuracy or completeness of any information on this site or found by following any link on this site. The owner will not be liable for any errors or omissions in this information nor for the availability of this information. The owner will not be liable for any losses, injuries, or damages from the display or use of this information. These terms and conditions of use are subject to change at anytime and without notice.

RE: European Union AI Act, and Our Use of Generative AI Tools and Agents Policy

All text on this site is composed by Charles Hugh Smith or by a credited guest-author. No Generative AI Tools are used in the composition / writing of any text or graphic content created by Charles Hugh Smith. This site deploys no AI agents or generative AI tools. This site is not responsible for the disclosures, use or non-use of AI agents or generative AI tools in advertisements displayed by Investing Channel or other ad placement services.

Audio files generated by text-to-audio transcription tools are identified as such.

Our Privacy Policy:

Correspondents' email is strictly confidential. This site does not collect digital data from visitors or distribute cookies. Advertisements served by third-party advertising networks such as Investing Channel may use cookies or collect information from visitors for the purpose of Interest-Based Advertising; if you wish to opt out of Interest-Based Advertising, please go to Opt out of interest-based advertising (The Network Advertising Initiative) If you have other privacy concerns relating to advertisements, please contact advertisers directly.

PRIVACY NOTICE FOR EEA INDIVIDUALS

This section covers disclosures on the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) for users residing within EEA only. GDPR replaces the existing Directive 95/46/ec, and aims at harmonizing data protection laws in the EU that are fit for purpose in the digital age. The primary objective of the GDPR is to give citizens back control of their personal data. Please follow the link below to access InvestingChannel's General Data Protection Notice.
https://stg.media.investingchannel.com/gdpr-notice/

Notice of Compliance with The California Consumer Protection Act

This site does not collect digital data from visitors or distribute cookies. Advertisements served by a third-party advertising network (Investing Channel) may use cookies or collect information from visitors for the purpose of Interest-Based Advertising. If you do not want any personal information that may be collected by third-party advertising to be sold, please follow the instructions on this page: Do Not Sell My Personal Information.

Regarding Cookies:

This site does not collect digital data from visitors or distribute cookies. Advertisements served by third-party advertising networks such as Investing Channel may use cookies or collect information from visitors for the purpose of Interest-Based Advertising; if you wish to opt out of Interest-Based Advertising, please go to Opt out of interest-based advertising (The Network Advertising Initiative) If you have other privacy concerns relating to advertisements, please contact advertisers directly.

Our Commission Policy:

Though I earn a small commission on Amazon.com books and gift certificates and gold (BullionVault) purchased via links on my site, I receive no fees or compensation for any other non-advertising links or content posted on my site.

Copyright Notice:

All original images (Drawings and Photographs), text (essays, books and works of fiction), audio and video recordings, musical compositions, graphic design, graphic design elements and HTML coding on this site are the copyrighted work of Charles Hugh Smith unless otherwise credited or noted. They are published as information for the private use of site visitors, and any reproduction or redistribution of this content or coding in any media in any format or distribution channel (text, audio, video/film, web) without the written permission of the copyright holder is strictly prohibited. All rights in all media reserved globally.

  © Blogger templates Newspaper III by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP